What is a self-refuting argument?

What is a self-refuting argument?

A self-refutation argument is the claim that some counterintuitive philosophical position undermines itself. Imagine Socrates told someone that he knows that he knows nothing. His respondent could use a self-refutation argument to point out that Socrates cannot take such a position.

What is the theory of determinism and why is it said to be self-defeating?

Proponents of the Determinism-Is-Self-Defeating Argument (hereafter referred to as DISDA) claim that all pro-deterministic arguments, if successful, undermine rationality and epistemic justification. Hence, the self-defeating nature of determinism.

Whats the meaning of refuting?

Definition of refute transitive verb. 1 : to prove wrong by argument or evidence : show to be false or erroneous. 2 : to deny the truth or accuracy of refuted the allegations.

Is relativism self-refuting?

a. Relativism is Self-Refuting. A doctrine is self-refuting if its truth implies its falsehood. Relativism asserts that the truth-value of a statement is always relative to some particular standpoint.

What is the definition of self-defeating?

: serving or tending to defeat oneself or itself : counterproductive: such as. a : acting to defeat its own purpose a self-defeating argument You kind of realize that violence can be a self-defeating strategy, because it just gives the other guy an incentive to attack you back in revenge.— Stephen Pinker.

What is a synonym for self-defeating?

Synonyms:impossible, trying, awkward, intolerable, thorny, critical, testing, delicate, intractable.

What is concession and refutation?

Concede: Admit that another person is right about something. Refute: Prove that someone else is wrong about something. Often, speakers of English will concede a point, only to refute a larger issue: It’s true that working can be tedious.

Is Nietzsche a relativist?

Nietzsche is not a relativist, but many of his positions – especially his perspectivism and his skepticism about the objectivity of morality – have influenced twentieth-century proponents of relativism and inspired associations with their theories of truth, knowledge, science, culture, ethics, and metaethics.

What is a self-defeating ie self contradictory theory or claim?

What is a self-defeating (i.e. self-contradictory) theory or claim? a theory or claim that proves to be false because it relies on the truth of a logical contradiction. What informal fallacy, if any, is committed in the following passage? “John smith is a jerk.”

What is another word for self-defeating?

What is another word for self-defeating?

self-destructive self-sabotaging
counterproductive dysfunctional
maladaptive dysregulated
futile

What is the meaning of inflated and deflated?

to release the air or gas from (something inflated, as a balloon): They deflated the tires slightly to allow the truck to drive under the overpass. to depress or reduce (a person or a person’s ego, hopes, spirits, etc.); puncture; dash: Her rebuff thoroughly deflated me. to reduce (currency, prices, etc.)

What is the difference between idealism and materialism?

Difference between Idealism and Materialism. Materialism is based on the idea that everything in the world is made up of matter or in other words, everything in the world is dependent on matter for its survival. Idealism, on the other hand, is a philosophy that proclaims that reality is actually nothing, but our mind,…

What is the materialist view?

“Materialism is the view that everything is ultimately material in nature. At the most fundamental level, everything that exists consists of nothing but matter and energy.

What is eliminative materialism?

Eliminative materialism is a materialist position in the philosophy of mind. Its primary claim is that people’s common-sense understanding of the mind is false and that certain classes of mental states that most people believe in do not exist.

What is materialism in psychology?

The Psychology of Materialism. At the deeper psychological level materialism is an attempted shortcut to happiness and well-being. It’s a substitution for entities like authentic human connection and satisfying productive work, entities that really do result in happiness and well-being but take a tremendous amount of courage and labor to obtain.