What does pending recommendation in PNAS mean?

The change in status from ‘Under review’ to ‘Pending recommendation’ means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised.

How long does it take for PNAS review?

PNAS has rapid turn times. The average time to first decision is 21 days; articles may be published as soon as 4 weeks after acceptance. PNAS supports open access.

What does under editor review mean PNAS?

If the Member Editor is satisfied too, they send the paper for peer review (probably indicated by ‘Under Review’). Once the peer review is complete, the Member Editor goes through the comments for their evaluation (probably indicated by ‘Under Editor Review’).

What does under editor review mean?

According to this answer: The status “under editor evaluation” indicates that the paper is now with the Associate Editor (AE) who will evaluate it based on the reviews and decide whether the paper should be accepted, rejected, or revised.

Is it hard to publish in PNAS?

Its impact factor is less than that of Science but nonetheless it is highly competitive. Publishing in PNAS is not an easy job even if you think your work is good enough. In general Science publishes strikingly novel work while Nature usually publishes extensive work.

Is PNAS a good journal?

PNAS is the second most cited scientific journal, with more than 1.9 million cumulative citations from 2008 to 2018. In the mass media, PNAS has been described variously as “prestigious”, “sedate”, “renowned”, and “high impact”. Since January 2019, PNAS is online-only, although print issues are available on-demand.

Is PNAS prestigious?

Nature, Science, and PNAS are the three most prestigious general-science journals, and Nature and Science are among the most influential journals overall, based on the journal Impact Factor (IF).

Is PNAS a high impact journal?

The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), the official journal of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS), is an authoritative source of high-impact, original research that broadly spans the biological, physical, and social sciences.

Does decision in process mean rejection?

Answer: The status “Under Editor evaluation” indicates that your paper is going through the initial editorial screening. Thus, unfortunnately, a change in status from “Under Editor evaluation” to “Decision in process” generally indicates a desk rejection.

How long does under editor evaluation take?

When you submitted a paper, Editor will check requirements, journal scopes… If ok, they need to contact reviewers. After all invited reviewers accepted, your manuscript will be “under review”. This process is always around 1 month.

Is PNAS respected?

PNAS is the second most cited scientific journal, with more than 1.9 million cumulative citations from 2008 to 2018. In the mass media, PNAS has been described variously as “prestigious”, “sedate”, “renowned”, and “high impact”.

Is PNAS a top tier journal?

Most of these metrics place PNAS in the top tier of multidisciplinary journals. In 2017, PNAS had a Scopus Metrics CiteScore in the top 5%, an Eigenfactor in the top 6%, and a Journal Citation Reports impact factor in the top 8% of multidisciplinary journals.

What happens if you submit to PNAS without further review?

The Board may reject manuscripts without further review, or review and reject manuscripts that do not meet PNAS standards. More than 50% of submissions are declined at initial evaluation. A member editor is an NAS member who is an active scientist in the field most relevant to your research.

Who is on the PNAS editorial board?

The PNAS Editorial Board is made up of NAS members who are active scientists and experts in their fields. On submission, your paper is assigned to an Editorial Board member in one of the 31 NAS disciplines.

What constitutes prior publication in PNAS?

What constitutes prior publication must take into account many criteria, including the extent of review, and will be determined on a case-by-case basis. Related manuscripts that are in press or submitted elsewhere must be included with a PNAS submission.

How long does it take for PNAS to make a decision?

PNAS has rapid turn times. The average time to first decision is 21 days; articles may be published as soon as 4 weeks after acceptance.